The Lumineers released their fifth studio album, , on February 14, 2025 . While critical reception was polarized, many fans and reviewers debated whether it represents a "better" or more evolved version of the band compared to their previous work like Brightside or Cleopatra . Arguments for Automatic Being "Better"
But if you happen to hear a ghost banjo playing somewhere in the static of the internet… that might just be Automatic . And yeah. It might be better.
The Lumineers' journey to success was not an overnight phenomenon. The band members, Wesley Schultz (lead vocals, guitar), Joe Karnes (bass), and Jeremiah Green (drums), met while attending the University of Colorado. They began performing in local bars and clubs, honing their craft and developing their unique sound. After self-releasing their debut EP in 2009, they gained a loyal following and eventually signed with D Records in 2011.
But the leaked files tell a different story.