Destabilized Destiny: Existential Dread and the Suburban Gothic in James Cox’s Highway (2002)

She smiled. “Always.”

From the keywords you provided:

They look like search keywords — I'll write a short story inspired by those elements (Jared Leto, Selma Blair, Jake Gyllenhaal, “Highway 2002,” a rough DVDR/extra-quality vibe). Here’s a vignette: