Confidential Informant List For My City Exclusive File

Unless you are a defense attorney with a court order or a federal agent with a warrant, that list will remain exclusive —exclusively out of your reach.

The Fatal Ledger: Why an ‘Exclusive’ Confidential Informant List for My City Would Be a Catastrophe confidential informant list for my city exclusive

: Attempting to obtain, publish, or circulate information about someone being a CI can lead to serious legal consequences, including charges of obstruction of justice Exceptions for Defendants Unless you are a defense attorney with a

There is a vast chasm between disclosing an identity to a defense attorney (who is an officer of the court, bound by ethics rules) and publishing that identity on a city website or in a newspaper’s “exclusive” database. The Sixth Amendment guarantees a defendant’s right to confrontation; it does not guarantee the public’s right to identify every person who speaks to the police. In 1963, the Supreme Court case Brady v

In 1963, the Supreme Court case Brady v. Maryland changed everything. It requires prosecutors to disclose exculpatory evidence to the defense. If a confidential informant has a history of lying, mental instability, or recanting testimony, that informant’s name must be revealed to avoid a mistrial.

For those looking to understand how these systems function in a city, agencies follow strict internal protocols rather than public lists: Role of Confidential Informants - Special Report